
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Epidemiology Branch, National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina 27709 [M. T.]; Departments of Medicine and Community and Family Medicine and Norris Cotton Cancer Center, Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, New Hampshire 03755 [E. R. G., J. A. B.]; Center for Gastrointestinal Biology and Disease, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina 27599 [R. S. S.]; Department of Preventive Medicine, School of Medicine, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California 90033 [R. W. H.]; Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19111 [B. S. B.]; and Environmental Epidemiology Branch, Division of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD 20892 [K. A. M.]
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
30 µg/liter), nonreplete and borderline (3170
µg/liter), replete and adequate (71160 µg/liter), or replete and
high (>160 µg/liter). Analyses were based on multiple logistic
regression models, including age, sex, study center, energy, alcohol,
fiber, folate, and total fat intake, number of months between
colonoscopic examinations, smoking status, and aspirin use. Overall,
there was no statistically significant linear association between log
ferritin concentration and adenoma recurrence (P =
0.33). Risk of adenoma recurrence was modestly increased among
participants with ferritin concentrations >70 µg/liter relative to
those with lower ferritin (odds ratio, 1.39; 95% confidence interval,
0.962.02). This result seemed more pronounced among women than men.
Dietary intake of iron and red meat was inversely associated with
adenoma recurrence among participants with replete iron stores but not
consistently associated among those with nonreplete stores. Our
findings suggest that any role of iron stores and dietary iron in
influencing risk of colorectal adenoma recurrence is likely complex. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Most colorectal cancers appear to arise from adenomas, and research regarding the association between iron stores and these precursors could help elucidate the role of iron exposure early in the tumorigenic process. Two prior studies, both case-control in design, have examined risk of adenoma in relation to iron stores (6 , 11) . We used prospective data from a randomized prevention trial to examine the association between serum ferritin concentration as a measure of body iron stores and recurrence of adenomas. In a previous analysis in the same study population, we found an inverse association between dietary iron and adenoma recurrence (12) . In the present analyses, we also explored whether iron stores modified the relationship between dietary iron and adenoma risk.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All trial participants gave informed consent and were randomly assigned
using a two-by-two factorial design to four treatment groups:
ß-carotene plus placebo, vitamins C and E plus placebo, ß-carotene
plus vitamins C and E, and placebo only. Two complete follow-up
colonoscopies were conducted
1 year and 4 years after the qualifying
colonoscopy. At these follow-up examinations, any raised mucosal
lesions were excised, and microscopic slides were sent for review by
the study pathologist. Polyps were classified as either neoplastic
(adenoma) or nonneoplastic (hyperplastic polyp, lymphoid follicle, or
other type of lesion). A total of 751 patients (of 864 randomized)
completed the trial and had the year 4 colonoscopy examination. Of the
113 patients who did not complete the study, 44 died, 32 were no longer
interested in participating, 19 moved or became too ill to continue,
and 18 dropped out for unknown reasons. There was no effect of the
study agents on risk of new adenomas (13)
. In the present
analyses, as in our prior report of dietary iron and adenoma recurrence
(12)
, patients found to have one or more adenomas during
the interval after the year 1 exam up to and including the year 4 exam
were classified as cases, whereas those without adenomas were
classified as controls. We did not consider adenomas diagnosed at the
year 1 colonoscopy in determining case status because many of these
tumors were likely present at the time that patients enrolled in the
trial (13)
. Large and/or multiple adenomas occurred too
infrequently to permit an informative analysis.
Measurement of Serum Ferritin.
Venous blood was taken at enrollment in mineral-free vacuum tubes.
Aliquots of serum were frozen in polypropylene tubes and shipped to the
coordinating center at Dartmouth for storage. A blood chemistry panel
was performed shortly after receipt of the specimens and included
measures of alkaline phosphatase and aspartate aminotransferase.
Serum ferritin samples were assayed at the Fox Chase Cancer Center
using IMx ferritin assay kits (Abbott Laboratories), which are based on
a microparticle enzyme immunoassay. The probe/electrode assembly of the
IMx apparatus delivers the sample, diluent, antiferritin alkaline
phosphatase conjugate, and antiferritin-coated microparticles to an
incubation well. After incubation, an aliquot of reaction mixture is
transferred to a glass fiber matrix. The microparticles bind
irreversibly to the glass fiber matrix. Unbound material is removed,
4-methylumbelliferyl phosphate is added as substrate, and the
microparticle enzyme immunoassay optical assembly is used to measure
the fluorescent product against a standard curve computed from six
sample calibrators supplied with the kits. Laboratory personnel were
blinded to patients treatment assignments and colonoscopy outcomes.
Questionnaire Data.
At enrollment into the trial, patients completed a questionnaire that
included information about smoking history and use of vitamin and
mineral supplements. Nutrient intake was assessed from a
self-administered food frequency questionnaire (14)
given
before randomization. Patients estimated their frequency of intake and
usual portion size over the previous year for >100 food items. Average
dietary nutrient intakes per day were calculated based on the nutrient
content and reported portion size and frequency of consumption of each
food. In addition, a variable representing weekly frequency of red meat
consumption was created as a proxy for heme iron, which is much more
bioavailable than iron from other sources. The red meat frequency
measure was based on reported consumption of hamburger, beef, beef
stew, pork, veal/lamb, chili con carne, and mixed dishes with meat. We
excluded from our analyses data from 36 patients who reported eating
<3 foods a day, skipped >50 foods in the questionnaire, or reported
daily caloric intake <500 or >5000 kcal/day.
Data Analysis.
Our analyses focused on baseline serum ferritin concentration as a
measure of iron stores before the main risk period of the study, the
interval after the first (year 1) follow-up colonoscopy up to and
including the exit (year 4) colonoscopy. We first tested whether there
was a linear relationship between adenoma recurrence and ferritin
concentration, analyzed as a log-transformed continuous variable. We
then considered risk in relation to estimated iron stores: nonreplete
and low (ferritin
30 µg/liter), nonreplete and borderline (3170
µg/liter), replete and adequate (71160 µg/liter), or replete and
high (>160 µg/liter). This categorization scheme is based on recent
data regarding ferritin and iron absorption (15)
and
differs from methods used in previous studies, which usually grouped
participants into quartiles or quintiles of ferritin concentration
(11
, 16)
. We used a serum ferritin concentration of
70
µg/liter to indicate replete iron stores, relying on research
suggesting that serum ferritin concentration and iron absorption are
closely inversely correlated when ferritin concentration is <70
µg/liter, but that above this level iron absorption is minimal and
roughly equal to the estimated rate of loss of iron from the body
(15)
. We posited that effects of dietary iron on adenoma
risk would be particularly evident in patients with ferritin
concentrations >70 µg/liter because replete iron stores and minimal
iron absorption would increase exposure of colonocytes to luminal iron.
At ferritin concentrations <70 µg/liter, we hypothesized that there
would be only a weak association of iron intake with risk because
depleted iron stores and increased intestinal absorption of dietary
iron would limit colonocyte exposure to luminal iron.
We used unconditional logistic regression first to test for a linear trend of the continuous, log-transformed ferritin variable and, next, to estimate ORs2 and 95% CIs for categories of serum ferritin coded as dummy variables. A minimally adjusted model included age, sex, and center. A more fully adjusted model included intake of energy, alcohol, total dietary fiber, folate, and total fat; number of months between the year 1 and exit colonoscopies; smoking status; and aspirin use. Intakes of alcohol, fiber, folate, and fat were energy-adjusted by using the residuals from the regression of the nutrient on caloric intake (17) and categorized into quartiles. Although duration of follow-up was not clearly related to serum ferritin levels in bivariate analyses (data not shown), we included number of months between year 1 and year 4 colonoscopies as a covariate. We tested for linear trend by including an ordinal variable representing the scaled median value for each category in a logistic regression model while controlling for the same covariates listed above. Minimally and fully adjusted models included only those patients not missing information on any of the variables included in the fully adjusted model. Body mass index, vitamin/mineral supplement use, treatment group, and family history of colorectal cancer were not found to be associated with either serum ferritin concentration or adenoma recurrence in bivariate analyses and were not further considered as potential confounders. The distribution of ferritin concentrations differed between women and men; thus, we ran stratified models as well as models with ferritin concentration x sex category interaction terms.
We conducted two additional analyses to account for serum ferritin concentrations that may have been elevated for reasons other than high iron stores. First, because high serum ferritin is commonly observed in individuals with high alcohol consumption, liver problems, infection, or inflammation (18 , 19) , we excluded subjects with any of the following: aspartate aminotransferase >75 or alkaline phosphatase >150; history of chronic pancreatitis, chronic hepatitis, or cancer reported at baseline; or heavy alcohol consumption at baseline, defined as five or more alcoholic beverages a day. In a separate analysis, we excluded people with serum ferritin >161 µg/liter for women or 300 µg/liter for men (20) regardless of the reason for elevation. Results from analyses excluding these patients were not meaningfully different from those based on the full study population. Age was not associated with ferritin concentration in this study population and was not used as a basis for exclusion.
Lastly, for the logistic regression analyses of dietary iron, we used
three different measures of iron intake: total iron intake categorized
as <10 or
10 mg/day, tertiles of energy-adjusted iron intake, and
red meat intake in categories corresponding to <2, 2 to <5, and
5
servings/week. We ran models stratified on iron store repletion status
(
70, 70 µg/liter), as well as models with ferritin concentration
x dietary iron category interaction terms. The number of
participants reporting taking iron supplements at baseline
(n = 25) was too small to permit evaluation of the
association of iron supplement use with risk; we did not classify
multivitamin supplement users as iron supplement users to avoid
confusing a possible effect for supplemental iron with that of other
vitamins and minerals.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
30 µg/liter (Table 3)
70 µg/liter.
The association between ferritin concentration and adenoma recurrence
appeared to be stronger in women than in men (Table 4)
|
|
70 µg/liter.
Although intake of total dietary iron, energy-adjusted iron, and red
meat were all inversely associated with risk of adenoma recurrence in
patients with replete iron stores, these measures were less
consistently related to adenoma recurrence among patients with
nonreplete iron stores (Table 5)
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
70 µg/liter, in whom a higher
proportion of dietary iron should be absorbed. Two prior published reports, both from case-control studies, have evaluated the association between risk of colorectal adenomas and serum ferritin. In one of these reports, based on patients referred for colonoscopy because of suspicion of neoplasia, serum ferritin was strongly associated with an increased risk of adenomas (6) . In the other study, based on a true screening population of asymptomatic adults undergoing flexible sigmoidoscopy, serum ferritin was weakly (and not statistically significantly) associated with increased adenoma risk (11) . Our findings, based on a group of patients prospectively followed for adenoma recurrence, are consistent with the results from the latter study and indicate that any association between adenomas and iron stores is likely to be relatively modest overall. It is possible, however, that some individuals are more susceptible to the effects of iron stores because of inherited or other unmeasured environmental factors.
Other laboratory measures of iron status have also been examined, and most studies using serum iron and transferrin saturation (7, 8, 9) , although not all (21) , have reported a strong association with invasive cancer risk. Serum ferritin, the primary iron storage protein, is thought to be a more stable and informative indicator of iron stores than other measures (22) . A variety of conditions can cause serum ferritin levels to increase without a concomitant increase in iron stores (18 , 19) , and we lacked detailed information on these conditions. Nevertheless, results from analyses that excluded individuals with elevated ferritin concentrations regardless of underlying cause were not appreciably different from those that included these individuals.
We can offer no explanation, other than the play of chance, as to why the relationship between ferritin and adenoma recurrence appeared to differ between men and women, and we are unaware of any prior finding of differing thresholds for a ferritin effect by sex. Ferritin concentrations were generally higher in men, but our analyses used the same cutpoints for both sexes. Given the relatively older age of our study population, results in women are also unlikely to have been markedly influenced by the inclusion of premenopausal women. The ferritin concentrations observed in this study population are similar to those reported in other studies conducted among older populations (23 , 24) and support the notion that differences between men and women in serum ferritin concentrations decrease but do not disappear entirely, even at older ages (25 , 26) .
Iron in the lumen of the large bowel has been hypothesized to increase colorectal neoplasia, perhaps through DNA damage caused by pro-oxidant hydroxyl radicals formed by the Fenton reaction in the presence of ferrous iron (2) . Iron also appears to stimulate proliferation of tumor cells (3 , 4) , possibly through its role as a rate-limiting nutrient for neoplastic cells (5) . A possible effect of iron on tumorigenesis in the colorectum is especially intriguing because colonocytes may be directly exposed to high concentrations of unabsorbed iron in the gut lumen. If the principal effect of iron is to accelerate the transition from adenoma to cancer, then this could also explain the apparently stronger association between iron stores and invasive cancer as opposed to adenoma (6, 7, 8, 9) . The availability of serum drawn at entry to the study allowed us to assess iron stores at a period when subjects were known to be polyp-free. In consequence, however, our results may pertain only to the earlier phases of the adenoma-carcinoma sequence.
Prior studies of dietary iron and colorectal adenoma (27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32) have produced little support for an increased risk with greater iron intake. In fact, results of most of these studies suggest an inverse relationship between adenoma and iron intake, and in one of these studies (32) , as well as in prior analyses from our present population (12) , this apparent protective effect of dietary iron was statistically significant and pertained to both women and men. Whereas one report (11) described a positive association between iron intake and adenoma, this result largely related to iron supplements rather than iron from food sources. In our study, too few patients (n = 25) reported taking iron supplements at baseline to evaluate its association with risk of recurrence.
The suggestion in our data of a moderately increased risk of adenoma recurrence among persons with ferritin concentrations >70 µg/liter seems paradoxical in view of our finding that dietary iron was inversely associated with adenoma risk in these individuals. We considered iron from dietary sources only rather than total iron from both dietary and supplemental sources. This approach, however, seems an unlikely explanation for the inverse association that we observed because in our prior analyses (12) , supplemental iron was only weakly positively associated with adenoma recurrence, and supplement use was slightly inversely associated. An inverse association with dietary iron could reflect consumption of other protective factors correlated with iron in the diet, although the association persisted even after adjustment for intake of fiber and folate (12) . It is also possible that chance has contributed to these apparently conflicting observations.
The presence of iron in the colonic lumen is difficult to infer from dietary reports, in part because of variability in absorption of iron from the diet. When iron stores are not replete, serum ferritin is inversely correlated with iron absorption; however, when iron stores are replete, iron absorption appears to be minimal and not strongly related to serum ferritin concentration (15 , 33) . This finding suggested to us that less dietary iron would reach the colon in patients with low iron stores, and thus the relationship between dietary iron and adenoma risk might differ depending on serum ferritin concentration. In fact, in our data, the inverse association between intake of dietary iron and red meat was more consistent among those with replete iron stores than among those with nonreplete stores.
In addition to iron stores, dietary substances such as phytic acid, which chelates iron and renders it nonreactive (34) , and the form of iron (heme or nonheme) also influence iron absorption and add to the difficulty of predicting luminal iron exposure from dietary intake alone. Although we attempted to account for iron bioavailability by examining the effect of red meat in particular, other dietary factors that enhance or inhibit iron bioavailability and absorption were not corrected for in our models because such a correction would require meal-level dietary information (35) . However, consumption of vitamin C supplement, tea, and coffee, potentially important factors in iron bioavailability, was similar between cases and controls (13 , 36) .
In summary, we found no clear relationship between serum ferritin concentration and adenoma recurrence. Replete iron stores, as indicated by serum ferritin concentration >70 µg/liter, were modestly but not statistically significantly associated with increased risk of adenoma recurrence relative to nonreplete stores. Iron intake was inversely associated with adenoma recurrence among those with replete iron stores but was less clearly associated with adenoma recurrence among those whose stores were nonreplete. The results from our analyses seem somewhat paradoxical, and data from other human studies are still too scant to permit a clear assessment of the relationship between iron intake, iron stores, and colorectal tumor risk. Future studies of the role of iron in colorectal cancer development may be enhanced by consideration of the dietary bioavailability and absorption of ingested iron.
| Footnotes |
|---|
1 Present address and to whom requests for
reprints should be addressed, at Division of Population Science, Fox
Chase Cancer Center, 7701 Burholme Avenue, Philadelphia, PA 19111. ![]()
2 The abbreviations used are: OR, odds ratio; CI,
confidence interval. ![]()
Received 3/10/99; revised 12/31/99; accepted 4/12/00.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. T. Chan, J. Ma, G. J. Tranah, E. L. Giovannucci, N. Rifai, D. J. Hunter, and C. S. Fuchs Hemochromatosis Gene Mutations, Body Iron Stores, Dietary Iron, and Risk of Colorectal Adenoma in Women J Natl Cancer Inst, June 15, 2005; 97(12): 917 - 926. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. A. McGlynn, L. C. Sakoda, Y. Hu, R. E. Schoen, R. S. Bresalier, M. Yeager, S. Chanock, R. B. Hayes, and K. H. Buetow Hemochromatosis Gene Mutations and Distal Adenomatous Colorectal Polyps Cancer Epidemiol. Biomarkers Prev., January 1, 2005; 14(1): 158 - 163. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. J. Shaheen, L. M. Silverman, T. Keku, L. B. Lawrence, E. M. Rohlfs, C. F. Martin, J. Galanko, and R. S. Sandler Association Between Hemochromatosis (HFE) Gene Mutation Carrier Status and the Risk of Colon Cancer J Natl Cancer Inst, January 15, 2003; 95(2): 154 - 159. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Boyle and M. E. Leon Epidemiology of colorectal cancer Br. Med. Bull., December 1, 2002; 64(1): 1 - 25. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Cancer Research | Clinical Cancer Research |
| Cancer Epidemiology Biomarkers & Prevention | Molecular Cancer Therapeutics |
| Molecular Cancer Research | Cancer Prevention Research |
| Cancer Prevention Journals Portal | Cancer Reviews Online |
| Annual Meeting Education Book | Meeting Abstracts Online |